Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:06 pm Post subject: Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Ok, So after COUNTLESS hours (So long I thought of making a program to make this faster... Lol), I have gone through about 200+ programs,tested75+ of them, and then reviewed about 30 of them, If you program isnt here, Then It didnt make it to the review Stage. Sorry. I have reviewed many Programs and I have a list of the top 5 programs. Also I only went to review programs from 2009 till present time, I dont have enouhgt time to do till 2005 lol. Please no critisism thats too harsh, I did this because I felt like it would be a good idea.
Monster Truck Master ~ Game Engine
Total: Great |+ 21/27
Object Orrented: Good |+4.5/5
Commented: Ok |+ 3.5/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Excellent |+4.5/5
Usefullness: Usefull |+3.5/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Good|+3/5
Comment: Loved how well you used OOP. You were going for an engine and it is Great. Also Like how this follows Code Conventions.
Advice: Comment more.
Review #2:
Playing Multiple Music Files And Music Mixing ~ Sound Effects Engine
Total: Great |+ 22/27
Object Orrented: Good |+4/5
Commented: Ok |+ 3/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Excellent |+5/5
Usefullness: Very |+5/5
Follows Naming Conventions: No | 0/2
Originality: Very |+5/5
Comment: IU know Im commenting my own program ;p but I think I Think this is the most usefull program out there for turing music. Good Job ;p
Advice: Comment more, use naming conventions and quit being so fat! ;p
Review #3:
LGui ~ Custom Gui
Total: Great |+23.5/27
Object Orrented: Yes |+5/5
Commented: Some |+ 3/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Excellent |+5/5
Usefullness: Very |+5/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Mostly |+1.5/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: Great Custom G.U.I. Very usefull, Great Effort and a Great Job
Advice: Comment more.
Review #4:
Turing Collections ~ Custom Value holding system
Total: Great |+27/27
Object Orrented: Yes |+5/5
Commented: Yes |+5/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Excellent |+5/5
Usefullness: Very |+5/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Original |+5/5
Comment: Perfect, Exactly like Hash Map in Java Lol, Good Job
Advice: Learn from this guy.
Review #5:
Context_Menu ~ Custom Gui
Total: Great |+19/27
Object Orrented: Some |+3/5
Commented: Poor |+1.5/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Good |+4/5
Usefullness: Usefull |+4/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Mostly |+1.5/2
Originality: very Original |+5/5
Comment: Great add-on, great for any paint programs and more. Good Job
Advice: Comment more.
Review #6:
3D display Engine ~ 3D Engine
Total: Great |+20/27
Object Orrented: Some |+3/5
Commented: ok |+3/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Good |+4/5
Usefullness: Usefull |+4/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: Great 3D engine, and also credit to those who helped you. Good Job
Advice: Comment more and develope this using OOP.
Review #7:
String Class ~ String manipulation
Total: Great |+23.5/27
Object Orrented: Some |+5/5
Commented: ok |+2.5/5
Use of Constructs and Variables: Good |+5/5
Usefullness: Usefull |+4/5
Follows Naming Conventions: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Original |+5/5
Comment: Great 3D engine, and also credit to those who helped you. Good Job
Advice: Comment more and develope this using OOP.
Sound Effects: Great |+5/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Ok |+3/5
User Interface: Good |+3.5/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Not |+2.5/5
Comment: Cool Game, Love how everything flows very nicely. Great use of sound efffect and picutures, although I did notice that the game paused with the laser sound effect. Good Job
Advice: release Source Code, That way some one from Compsci can tell you what you did wrong
Sound Effects: good |+4/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Great |+5/5
Source Code: Yes | 2/2
Originality: Very |+5/5
Comment: Great game, one I will acually keep. It is quite obvious that you put many hours into this game for the amount of complexity, and visual effects. Good Job
Advice: Move on to another language and fast!
Sound Effects: Great | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: Yet again, great game, I Found this a very original Idea, except the main menu. Lack of sound made this uninteresting so I didnt play long, anyways, Good Job
Advice: Add music and source code!
Review #4:
Pacman ~ 2d arcade
Total: 16.5/27
Sound Effects: Ok |+3.0/5
Visual Effects: Ok |+3/5
GamePlay: Ok |+2.5/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: Yes | 2/2
Originality: Not really |+2/5
Comment: Dont get me wrong, This is a good project, but its lacking the detail and effort. I Also found it hard to move ingame.i did like the user interface, basic, but looked nice. Good Job
Advice: Not very original, improve gameplay and add visual effects.
Review #5:
Two Player Shooter ~ 3rd person shooter
Total: 22.5/27
Sound Effects: good |+4/5
Visual Effects: Great |+4.5/5
GamePlay: Good |+4/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: This is a great game. It is good overall and when you play this person spent alot of time and effort in this. Good Job
Advice: Add a main menu, and have some background music.
Review #6:
Sudoku ~ Puzzle
Total: 16.5/27
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Good |+5/5
User Interface: Good |+5/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Ok |+2.5/5
Comment: This is a good game. It has a great Interface, and is great when passing by time, I will accually keep this one. Good Job
Advice: Add some background music, and a cheat sheet to make sure you are correct. Dont forget source code!
Review #7:
Lights Off ~ Puzzle
Total: 24/27
Sound Effects: Great |+5/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Not Original |+2/5
Comment: This is a great game. Fun to play while bored. Good Job
Advice: Great job, Everything flows, now you just need to come up with your own Idea!
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Original |+3.5/5
Comment: This game had great visual effects and was great overal, No music however made this program kinda boring to play. Also The level maker didnt work. Good Job
Advice: Fix you level maker program, and add music.
Sound Effects: some |+2/5
Visual Effects: Poor |+2/5
GamePlay: Ok |+3/5
User Interface: Good |+3.5/5
Source Code: Yes |+2/2
Originality: Not Original |+2/5
Comment: This is an Ok game, There is nothing really different about it and nothing that stand out of the ordinary, anyways, Good Job
Advice: Spend a little more time and effort into the program.
Review #10:
Asteriods ~ Space
Total: 18/27
Sound Effects: Good|+4/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: poor |+2/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Ok |+3/5
Comment: This is a good fun game that is great if you wanna challenge your friends. There wasnt much of a menu, but anyways Good Job
Advice: Make your self a menu and instructions. Also dont forget Source Code.
Review #11:
Grail Quest ~ RPG
Total: 23.5/27
Sound Effects: Great |+5/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Great |+5/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Very Original |+4.5/5
Comment: This is a good fun game. Althogh, there is no story line... but anyways, Good Job
Advice: Fix Glitches, and just put more time into it. Also dont forget Source Code.
Review #12:
Click Click Revolution ~ Music Playing Simulation
Total: 14.5/27
Sound Effects: Ok |+3/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Great |+4/5
User Interface: Bad |+0.5/5
Source Code: Yes|+1/2
Originality: Not Original |+2/5
Comment: Ok Game, Works fine, but you can mash the keys and hit them al... Lol, Good Job
Advice: No menu, We are not asian and cant do that S*** Lol. Also Good you have source code, but dont shove all to one line...
Review #13:
Ace Warfare ~ 3D 3rd person Shooter
Total: 26/27
Sound Effects: Great |+5/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+4.5/5
User Interface: Great |+ 4.5/5
Source Code: Yes|+2/2
Originality: Very Original |+5/5
Comment: Funny how great games come from my school... Lol, This game is great, 3D which makes this great on its own. Great job.
Advice: None, I know you`ve moved on to java ;p, too bad ur brothers game wasnt as good as this one
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Ok |+3/5
Source Code: Yes|+2/2
Originality: Very Original |+5/5
Comment: had to review my own game. Great job.
Advice: Fr***in Add some sounds you fatty ;p
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Great |+5/5
Source Code: Yes|+2/2
Originality: Very Original |+5/5
Comment: This is probably the best and only TD in turing. Great job.
Advice: Add Sound effects
Review #16:
Racing ~ Racing
Total: 16.5/27
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+4.5/5
GamePlay: Great |+5/5
User Interface: Ok |+3/5
Source Code: No |+0/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: This is a fun, and completly customisable. Great job.
Advice: Add Sound effects, and better menu, and source code! add it!
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Great |+4/5
GamePlay: Good |+5/5
User Interface: Good |+4/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Original |+3.5/5
Comment: This is a great game. Worth playing, just is dull playing with no music or sound effects. Good Job
Advice: Add some background music, fix the map editor glitch if you click off the screen and add source code!
Review #18:
Platformer ~ 2d Platform
Total: 17/27
Sound Effects: None | 0/5
Visual Effects: Good |+4/5
GamePlay: Great |+4.5/5
User Interface: Great |+4.5/5
Source Code: No | 0/2
Originality: Original |+4/5
Comment: This is a good game. Short and sweet, kinda boring without music or sound fx but still Good Job.
Advice: Add some background music and add source code!
Sponsor Sponsor
SNIPERDUDE
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:19 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Wow, I'm honoured I made it to the list, thank you. I have finished working on the project (even though I had many unpublished features), I have decided to revive it in Python. I'll post when done any significant amount. And I'll comment more. I rather enjoyed making such a project.
I was actually shocked I didn't see Forces up on there, the game created by Windsurfer.
copthesaint
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:25 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Forces ? Maybe I didnt get to it... :/ I Had literally went on ever post in submissions and downloaded lol. After 5 pages I was getting into 2008 and stuff from 2005 so I said "screw it, I'm just reviewing 2009-present date" lol
I searched forces but thats from 2006, hence I didnt review it.
SNIPERDUDE
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:28 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
If you haven't played it, please do. It will be the most fun you will ever have playing a Turing made game. Although he seemed to disappear after the game's code was released.
copthesaint
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:36 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Yea thats pretty intese :p
Not being rated, but http://compsci.ca/v3/viewtopic.php?t=13809&highlight=forces
Also you did tie with a bunch of people for 5th, but You did put in WAY more effort then the others + I didnt wanna put multiple names for 5th ;p
SNIPERDUDE
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:39 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Thanks, I did work hard on it. It was especially a challenge getting complex graphics from just using Turing's built-in commands. Totally worth it though, put Turing's built-in GUI to shame.
copthesaint
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 9:44 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
LOL I love this game also Force, Is made at Timmins High! Mr.Reids Class :p
All the awsome games come from my school ;p This also makes me feel prowd
Ill Ask too see if he know what ever happened to wind surfer
BigBear
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 10:31 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
You should have listed the user that create such submissions and maybe a link to the post
Sponsor Sponsor
DemonWasp
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 2:41 am Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
That's gratifying to see my work listed as "learn from this guy" up there. Thanks!
I'm encouraged to actually write some physics programming tutorials (I have the code for the first one finished, but haven't sat down to actually write the tutorial yet). Quick survey: how many people would be interested enough in a physics-programming tutorial to warrant me writing 5+ pages of text for it?
Turing_Gamer
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:26 am Post subject: Re: Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Nice list I agree with all of you. Kinda sad that my programs didn't make it... Oh well, wasn't the best anyway. Should have added how many hours each game took to make.
Insectoid
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:46 am Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
I'd like some links/names on there too, can't tell if the pacman@#4 is mine or someone else's. The comments describe mine well. I'd be surprised if that WAS mine though, I made that in grade 10 before I knew much at all, most of that stuff I was learning as I went. Never finished it and parts don't work.
jdubzisyahweh
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 11:26 am Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 12:36 pm Post subject: Re: Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
But is it as good as for example Ace Warfare?
DemonWasp
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 3:39 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Funnily enough, 12.6 thousand lines of code isn't grounds for "good", it's grounds for "bad". You can do an awful lot in 12.6k lines, far more than a Millionaire game.
copthesaint
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 4:23 pm Post subject: RE:Best of Turing, Jan 2009-Feb 2010
Lol Thinking back to that now, Names probably would have been a good idea... Lol :/ How can I edit my top post? I think adding the names would kinda be a good idea ;p
Register
Wiki
Blog
Search
Turing
Chat Room
Members
