// you’re reading...

Education

Software piracy in schools

tux the pirate avatar

There is some buzz in world news on the state of software piracy in schools. Specifically in Russia, where a highly controversial case emerged over the use of a certain Operating System for educational purposes. Considering that Russia has one of the highest piracy rates in the world, the entire situation seems kind of ludicrous.

a principal of a public school in a small village somewhere in the middle of Russia is accused of using an unlicensed copies of Microsoft Windows on school’s computers, and the penalty could be as high as five years in prison.

World Trade Organization current members

Interestingly enough Microsoft wasn’t even the one to initiate this legal action. It is suspected that the Russian government itself is behind the initiative, in a bid to enter the World Trade Organization. Though I’m not about to write on world politics, or economic state of Russian population. My interest is in students.

Do students pirate software?

  • Students have little disposable income
  • Students don’t see a value in investing in a software license
  • Students are familiar with file distribution networks
  • There is little legal repercussion for highschool students below the age of majority

This creates a problem with schools using proprietary software to teach courses. If the distribution license does not extend pass the classroom’s lab, each student is thrown into a dilemma at the sight of the first assignment – where to get a copy of the software used? I’ve been to classes that required AutoCAD drawings handed in. That is a $4000 piece of software, and even a greatly discounted student license did not seem reasonable at $400. “I just need to do this homework assignment…”

What I think should be done

Open Source Software is often a reasonable choice. Open Office is equivalent to Microsoft Office, is compatible with all major office suites, and is simply free. French authorities recognize this, and promote open source software in schools. Reports, presentations, spreadsheets – check!

Other times it’s a tradeoff between available software, and software that’s actually being used in the industry. Alfred Thompson writes about choosing a Visual Studio flavour for use in school computer labs. At the student level, Microsoft’s Express Edition products are not too far off from the Professional counter-parts, but are free to use. Students like free.

So both companies, and educational institutions need to realize that professional industry and students make up two different groups with two different objectives. Students don’t have as much money as industry does, but they want to learn, and industry needs them to learn. The software needs to be more readily available to students, and not force them into obtaining it via other means. That just teaches a bad lesson.

Read more

Discussion

  1. Posted by Greg Wilson | February 10, 2007, 9:20 pm

    Open Office is also bloated, slow, and buggy, and while I wouldn’t have believed it possible, its UI makes Microsoft Office look good. It puzzles me that students will spend hundreds of dollars every year on textbooks, but balk at spending any fraction of that on software…

    Reply to comment

  2. Posted by Tony | February 10, 2007, 11:11 pm

    Odd, Open Office works wonders for my occasional reports. Though to be honest I’d invest into a good code editor over an office suite (priorities, right?).

    It’s an interesting observation on textbooks. Most applications cost less than a heavy Math textbook, and last for longer than a semester. On the other hand, if the school expenses are stretching the budget as it is, it might be tempting to not pay for software. It’s incredibly easier to copy a long string of 1s and 0s than it is to steal a 4 lb book.

    Reply to comment

  3. Posted by Jarek Piórkowski | February 12, 2007, 1:03 am

    I think a better comparison would be photocopying a book instead of physically stealing a copy. (When you pirate AutoCAD, you don’t go into the TechShop and snatch a box…)

    Of course, if there existed a widely-available machine that was able to turn the pages and copy each page automatically, I think you’d see a lot less people buying books.

    Reply to comment

  4. Posted by Tony | February 12, 2007, 2:12 am

    That’s exactly why it’s easier to steal software, it’s pure information. There’s no physical barrier or a security guard to tuckle you down.

    And there is a book scanner that turns up the quality on your intellectual crime, although it doesn’t turn pages… yet. I know you’re in just about the correct program to design that extension though ;)

    Though I’ve also noticed that the local Kinko’s and all University’s copy places have big warning signs – Do not photocopy textbooks. So I guess quite a number of students have already tried that practice.

    Reply to comment

Post a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>